I'm sure there will be further editions as I find material.
The reading period for the IYFG awards is a time when I read little else except nominated stories. This time the new screening process made that much less painful as a record number of nominations didn't make it to the voting list and those that remained were of a higher average quality. There were still stories that, while otherwise well written (or not), contained things that have gone past mildly irritating to me and whose presence is enough for me to not vote for story, or in some cases even read any further.
I have noted on my own, and had my observation supported by comments at Fic Bitches, that there are certain repeating themes that bad or immature writers (not always the same) seem drawn to like flies to a dead horse. Here are some that are getting on my nerves in no particular order:
1. Insta-Angst: Just add characters.
Young people seem to adore wallowing in angst for angst sake. Mature adults have enough real angst in their lives without getting extra doses from their fiction. Insta-Angst is a term I coined when jotting notes down about nominated stories. It refers to the stupid writer's trick of using an increasingly improbable series of coincidences and misunderstandings to maximize the angst quotient in a story beyond what could reasonably be expected given the starting situation and the characters. Not that the characters will stay in character if doing so will reduce the angst.
Now, increasingly improbable coincidences and misunderstandings can be great fun, if you are watching a comedy like Some Like it Hot, but in a Serious Fanfic it's slow torture.
Not an actual plot from any one story but here is the sort of thing I mean. Character A loves B but thinks B doesn't like her in that way even though he does and she overhears gossip that he is going out with C and angsts. Then she tries to distance herself from B and B angsts because she is getting more distant from him and why oh why can't he get up the guts to tell her how he feels even though he is sure she doesn't feel that way and this proves it. This even if in canon A would have immediately confronted B about C or at least verified the gossip before believing it.
Then either A or B nearly dies and the other one sits by the bedside and angsts. Or one of them leaves town to start a new life and both angst about the distance...I can't keep this up. Even in abstract it's making me ill.
2. The healing light of his cock.
I found this phrase at Fic Bitches and despite the public mocking of stories using this concept there and elsewhere it continues to be a favorite with Lemon writers. This is when a character's problems, no matter how serious, are all solved by a roll in the hay with your one true love. Even if he's someone you thought you hated right up until you got naked together. Even if you are a guy who thought he was straight right up until you got naked together.
Entire family murdered brutally? Scared that your father will disown you when he finds out you are gay? Overwhelmed by fear and misguided guilt after being raped? Once you are bathed in the healing light of his cock it will all go away because you will then be soul mates and will be able to face anything together. His love will heal you and make you whole It will probably also fix your credit score, get out tough stains, and reveal the secrets of how to win at poker.
3. Incest slash.
It seems that just putting two men in bed together isn't an illicit thrill anymore so let's kick it up a notch and slash brothers. I'm not sure which is more disturbing, the stories based on brothers who totally don't get along in canon or the ones where they have a close (but not THAT close) relationship.
In Inuyasha fandom Inuyasha and Sesshoumaru are winding up in bed with Inu taking on the submissive role. In one memorable instance (I really wish it weren't, I need that melon baller Christina, STAT) the author does acknowledge the history of warfare between the two by having Sess murder Inu right after intercourse.
Over in Full Metal Alchemist land it's Al and Ed even though Al's body was destroyed in a mystical accident and his soul walks around in a suit of animated armor. It's like writing pr0n about the Tin Man but ickier since in canon Ed is 15 and Al is about 11 or 12. Hey, incest slash isn't enough, you really need underage incest slash for that extra spice. Nevermind how they manage to do anything at all logic is not welcome here.
4. Turning men into teenage girls.
No, not literally. Well, at least not in THIS instance; that story was actually a little funny. I mean slash stories where one of the guys, no matter how macho in canon, inevitably starts behaving like a teenage girl. He becomes weepy, and clingy and utterly co-dependent. He will angst about whether or not his partner really loves him or is just using him for sex. He gets jealous. He starts to cook and clean for his lover. It's really disturbing to see Inuyasha cry over finally being accepted by his brother as they hold each other after sex. It's even more disturbing to see Sesshoumaru and Kouga have a cat fight over him. Stop. Now. Please.
5. Making one half of a canon pair behave OOC to justify breaking them up so one of them can end up with someone else.
Frequently paired with either full blown insta-angst or at least just the improbable coincidence part of it. Writers of this bilge, it doesn't matter if that someone else is another canon character or a Mary Sue, if you have to manipulate things that much to make it work you need to re-think your plot. It is not believable to anyone but you.
6. Rape as foreplay.
Any author who writes a scene that starts out with one character raping another only to have it turn into hot monkey sex with the former victim begging for more needs to be grounded from the computer for a year and be compelled to spend that time helping out at a rape crisis center. Writers of these stories tend to be female and young. Scary ain't it?
Some of these plots show up in pro fic too and people get paid for it. That's nearly as scary.